No — that’s the answer a robbery defendant received from a Garvin County judge Thursday in response to his request to withdraw a previously submitted no contest plea.
Michael Shaw, 38, received his day in a Pauls Valley courtroom — something District Judge Candace Blalock ruled he voluntarily gave up when he submitted the new plea in a case that accuses him of brutally attacking an 80-year-old Lindsay man last December and taking the man’s two wallets filled with thousands of dollars.
“We had a jury to hear this case. The state was ready to bring up witnesses. I was very careful on how we proceeded with this,” Blalock said during Thursday’s hearing for Shaw. “It appears to me that he could have had his day in court and he chose not to take it.”
The judge’s comments came after arguments for the plea withdrawal were made by Shaw’s new defense attorney, Elton Jenkins of Norman.
“He’s saying the new plea was invalid. He’s asking for a new trial,” Jenkins said during the hour-long hearing in Garvin County District Court.
“My client offered the plea through influence, more specifically coercion,” he said.
The reference is to Shaw’s no contest plea being submitted only moments before the start of his jury trial that had been scheduled to start in mid-September.
At that time, Shaw’s court-appointed attorney was Dee Graves of Pauls Valley. Graves was the target of Shaw’s request to withdraw the plea and return the case to the trial stage.
“He entered the plea because he did not have confidence in his previous attorney,” Jenkins.
It was a position quickly targeted by George Burnett, an assistant district attorney in Garvin County.
“Kill the messenger. That’s what you got here,” Burnett said. “The defendant didn’t like what he heard so he blamed his attorney.”
“There are tons of evidence in this case. That’s why he took a plea,” Burnett said.
Graves earlier took the stand to claim he thought Shaw’s lack of confidence in him as a defense attorney stemmed from the belief he was working with prosecutors from the same district attorney’s office where he used to work.
“His concern was I was working for the DA’s office,” he said.
Graves said this comment from Shaw came when the two had a discussion last month after the defendant made a formal request to withdraw his plea while also getting a new court-appointed attorney.
“At the time he requested another attorney I spoke with Mr. Shaw and he expressed his concerns with me. I told him those concerns were unfounded,” Graves said.
“I explained to him his options. I told him he could hire an attorney, that he keep a court-appointed attorney but it would have to be me and the third option as for him to represent himself,” Graves said.
At that time Shaw stuck with Graves but later pushed to have him replaced.
Shaw also claimed to submit the new plea on the belief his mother had made that request. He claimed Graves led him to believe something that was false.
It was a claim Graves adamantly denied as he spoke from the witness stand.
“I didn’t tell him that his mother wanted him to plead guilty,” Graves said. “I believe Mr. Shaw thought I was leading him in the wrong direction or force him to do something he didn’t want to do.”
With the judge’s ruling now in the books, a hearing will be scheduled for Shaw’s sentencing, which could result in him receiving a prison term of 20 years to life.
It was also pointed out a previous deal offered by Burnett but turned down by Shaw would have resulted in him getting a 10-year prison term.
Local News
No trial for robbery suspect
- Local News
-
-
It’s now official for county trust
A Garvin County trio made it official Monday by creating a brand new public trust authority designed to help area school districts after bond issues are OK’d by voters.
-
DNA findings put trial on hold
A jury trial will have to wait for one of five suspects accused of committing home invasions in two Garvin County cities back in the fall of 2010.
-
Retirement is full circle for Paoli principal
Throughout the history of any town, whether it is as big as Oklahoma City or in this case as small as Paoli, there are always natives remembered for going above and beyond the rest.
-
Delta to stuff bus for soldiers
As Memorial Day weekend is set to offer yet another chance to celebrate in the names of individuals who have sacrificed so much for America, Delta Public Transit has plans to help those whose service is either current or much more recent.
-
Swinging summer
-
Splash time for pool project
Hoping to make a big splash while thinking outside the box are a number of officials involved in the planning for an outdoor swimming pool facility in Pauls Valley.
-
End of School Honors
-
PVGH program more familiar patient care
While not all of the wounds have healed since the most difficult changes to Pauls Valley General Hospital via a control shift over to the St. Anthony Health System took place, some of the brighter days have already come from a new care position started on March 5.
-
Sides drawn in shooting case
A shooting earlier this week has one Pauls Valley man awaiting criminal charges for what some witnesses described as action done to protect others.
-
Disposal site protest now official
Now it’s wait and see time for a bunch of Pauls Valley area landowners who have completed a petition opposing a proposed oil field waste disposal site.
- More Local News Headlines
-
FAMU Bandmates: Victim Volunteered to Be Hazed
Raw Video: Bride Who Faked Cancer Released
Raw Video: Tornado Appears During Wedding
HP to Cut 27,000 Jobs, Save Up to $3.5B
Inquiry Hears Wider Secret Service Misbehavior
Md. 911 Dispatcher Caught Sleeping on Job
Raw Video: Toddler Trapped in Washing Machine
Iowa Man With Zebra, Parrot in Truck Gets DUI
Egyptians Pick New President in Free Election
Giant Bull Head Draws Drivers to South Dakota
Astrodome Fades As Houston Decides Fate
Franciscan Files Tell Stories of Priest Abuse
Wildfire Destroys 2 Homes
Flight Diverted After Suspicious Note
Joplin Remembers Deadly Tornado, 1 Year Later
Panel Recommends Against Routine Prostate Test
Fired Lingerie Employee Claims Discrimination
Facebook Shares Continue Negative Slide
Cuba Waiting for Cyber Age to Come
8 Hurt in Oklahoma Shooting After NBA Playoff
